spinning vs baitcasting

[CorneliaGale]

Baitcasters take a lot of practice to learn how to use plus you have to teach your thumb to feather the spool at the end of the cast. set the spool drag a little to the tight side start throwing and as you get your thumb working, loosen the spool drag and keep throwing, with enough professional overrides and practice you learn when to feather and when to let it go.

[mwardncsu]

Yeah - for me the issue at night is now always knowing exactly where the bank is, and thus not feathering the spool at the right time before it hits the bank/water.....

[getlinewet]

This video helped me solve the backlash problem with baitcasters:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=TDI5kwR5zjc

Use the thumb trick

[Gotcha]

www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqSAS2K6Cng&feature=youtube_gdata_player
www.youtube.com/watch?v=WoyqGqBBO10&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Skipping docks and long distance abus! Not for beginners!

[Red Bear]

i prefer spinning to bait casting reels myself. i do own a couple of the round abu garcia bait casters and i about got things where i barely backlash anymore. it seems like an overhand cast is barely possible with a bait caster though, its instant backlash. also, id have to disagree that you cant horse a fish with spinning gear, ive done it more than once, its small line that many people prefer on spinning reels is why they cant horse fish in. but spinning gear doesnt have to mean finesse fishing and small line.

oh, and anyone who can skip docks with a baitcaster is damn good with one id have to say, thats usually a method reserved for spinning reels...

[BentRod]

I'm probably weird but I like spinning reels for jigging and bait casters for casting. If you set the set the tension knob right, bait casters aren't too bad and I think you can be a lil more accurate but both have their place. Ask a bass fisherman, he prob knows the right answer.

For live bait, it's only bait casters for me pretty much unless I put out some light tackle fun rods.

[mytoyzfishing]

For me if its live bait or cut bait its non-spinning setups. Jigging I use baitcast. The rest its been spinning setups, but have been playing around with baitcast setups here lately. I'd rather be fishing then undoing birds nest's

[latenitebite]

thanks for the info,& replies, i guess they do both have a place, instead of trying to pick the one for me, ill just have to pick the one for the job

[striperjohn]

Baitcasters are used simply because they allow more precise casting (99% of Bass Pros use baitcasters), handle heavier lures and baits, and bigger fish. For example look at the size required of spinning reels versus baitcasters. Most baitcast reels will handle up to 40lb test monofilament with ease. Try that with spinning reels-they would be enormous. With the new lines out that does allow spinning reels to use much heavier line, however most manufacturers will tell you the gearing, brakes, and drags on the spinning reels will not handle the wear and tear like a baitcaster will. Copied this from a forum on the same subject:
Bait Casting Reels and Its Advantages


Bait casting reels are often used by experienced anglers who enjoy catching big fish such as pike, salmon, and bass. While these reels are great for luring large fish, it does take time to perfect the casting technique. Some of the advantages of using a baitcaster, instead of a spincaster, are farther casting, more precise lure placement, and better leverage.

Bait casting reels usually sit above the rod. The reason it can be difficult to master is because it requires the use of your thumb to control the spool and lure placement. Many beginners who try to use this type of reel usually have problems with backlash. Backlash is when the line gets tangled in the spool. Another name for this tangling problem is called a bird's nest'.

Baitcasters are better for catching bigger fish because they are made for fishing and using heavier lures and heavier lines. The heavier lures enable the angler to fish at higher speeds. You can take full advantage of baits such as spinners and crankbaits. The heavier lines are great for fighting bigger fish such as bass. You are able to put more pressure on the line without the fear of it snapping.

Another advantage of this tool is more control and better lure placement. Often times, bass fishing requires you to place the lure in a precise spot. This precise placement can be difficult with spincasters, due to lack of control. Once you get that big fish on the hook, you have a better chance of landing it due to the increased leverage, since the reel sits closer to the rod.

The main disadvantage of bait casting reels is the steeper learning curve. Most fishermen have used spincasters since they first learned to fish. Casting is almost automatic with this reel. However, with the baitcaster, your thumb is in contact with the spool, which gives the angler more control. In order to reap the benefits of this fishing reel, you will need to practice casting or you will spend most of your fishing trip fixing bird's nests.

Spincast reels can also get the job done. Many fishermen have been hooking fish for many years using this reel. It won't become obsolete anytime soon. However, one of the biggest advantages of using the baitcaster is your accuracy. You'll be able to place your lure in small spaces. Bait casting reels are the way to go if you don't want to risk losing your trophy fish on the line. Given all of its advantages, it will be worth the time it takes to perfect this reel.


Bait casting reels have many advantages over spin cast reels. Many fishermen are hesitant to use the baitcaster because it can be frustrating to learn. Once you master the proper technique, you can enjoy its many benefits. You can visit this article about Bait Casting Reels to get more information.

[CorneliaGale]

Nice post striperjohn, says it all, I been using baitcasters for years, first bass I caught was I had to hand line in because of the birdsnest on the reel would not let me reel it in. years later I still get them only now not as bad as I learned to stop them before they get too bad.

[williamgdabrowski]

A spinning reel is maybe the foremost common style of fishing pole among anglers, particularly those going when tiny to medium-sized fish like bass, redfish, and crappie. These reels have a set spool beneath the rod, and line is drawn out by the burden of the lure, bait, or tackle.



A simple definition for a baitcaster could be a reel that features a revolving spool and sits on high of a casting rod with a trigger handle. this can be specifically opposite to a spinning reel, that sits beneath a fishing pole and with the road guides facing down.

[janejskelton]

my opinion is if you are not a pro level fisher than must try spinning reel. it hassles free and easy to use. I also use a spinning reel.